*Updated March 26, 2024
| Rank | Name | School | Score | Date |
| 1. | Karin Lichey | Georgia | 40.000 | 2/23/96 |
| 2. | Mohini Bhardwaj | UCLA | 39.975 | 3/18/01 |
| 3. | Suzanne Metz | Utah | 39.950 | 3/25/95 |
| 4. | Jordan Bowers | Oklahoma | 39.925 | 3/23/24 |
| Haleigh Bryant | LSU | 39.925 | 3/8/24 | |
| Maggie Nichols | Oklahoma | 39.925 | 2/17/17 | |
| 7. | Jordan Chiles | UCLA | 39.900 | 3/11/23 |
| Jamie Dantzscher | UCLA | 39.900 | 3/3/02 | |
| Selena Harris | UCLA | 39.900 | 3/16/24 | |
| Kristen Kenoyer | Utah | 39.900 | 3/6/93 | |
| Courtney Kupets | Georgia | 39.900 | 4/17/09 | |
| Maggie Nichols | Oklahoma | 39.900 | 2/4/18 | |
| Maggie Nichols | Oklahoma | 39.900 | 3/3/18 | |
| Maggie Nichols | Oklahoma | 39.900 | 1/20/20 | |
| Trinity Thomas | Florida | 39.900 | 2/12/21 | |
| Trinity Thomas | Florida | 39.900 | 4/2/22 | |
| 17. | Jeanette Antolin | UCLA | 39.875 | 2/22/04 |
| Haleigh Bryant | LSU | 39.875 | 3/10/23 | |
| April Burkholder | LSU | 39.875 | 3/21/03 | |
| Jade Carey | Oregon State | 39.875 | 2/18/23 | |
| Jade Carey | Oregon State | 39.875 | 2/24/23 | |
| Jordan Chiles | UCLA | 39.875 | 3/5/23 | |
| Jenny Hansen | Kentucky | 39.875 | 95 | |
| Jenny Hansen | Kentucky | 39.875 | 94 | |
| Ashley Kelly | Arizona State | 39.875 | 3/10/06 | |
| Ashley Kelly | Arizona State | 39.875 | 2/27/04 | |
| Ashley Kelly | Arizona State | 39.875 | 3/21/03 | |
| Karin Lichey | Georgia | 39.875 | 98 | |
| Maggie Nichols | Oklahoma | 39.875 | 1/21/17 | |
| Emily Pritchard | Washington | 39.875 | 3/12/04 | |
| Trinity Thomas | Florida | 39.875 | 3/31/22 | |
| Melissa Vituj | Utah | 39.875 | 2/27/04 | |
| Leanne Wong | Florida | 39.875 | 2/23/24 | |
| Leanne Wong | Florida | 39.875 | 4/2/22 | |
| 35. | Maggie Nichols | Oklahoma | 39.8625 | 4/15/17 |
| Trinity Thomas | Florida | 39.8625 | 4/16/22 | |
| 37. | Jeanette Antolin | UCLA | 39.850 | 1/10/04 |
| Luisa Blanco | Alabama | 39.850 | 3/8/24 | |
| Jordan Bowers | Oklahoma | 39.850 | 3/17/24 | |
| Sierra Brooks | Michigan | 39.850 | 1/12/24 | |
| Haleigh Bryant | LSU | 39.850 | 3/1/24 | |
| Jade Carey | Oregon State | 39.850 | 3/31/22 | |
| Jordan Chiles | UCLA | 39.850 | 2/26/23 | |
| Ashley Kelly | Arizona State | 39.850 | 3/12/04 | |
| Courtney Kupets | Georgia | 39.850 | 2/28/09 | |
| Karin Lichey | Georgia | 39.850 | 1/16/99 | |
| Maggie Nichols | Oklahoma | 39.850 | 2/3/17 | |
| Maggie Nichols | Oklahoma | 39.850 | 3/18/18 | |
| Maggie Nichols | Oklahoma | 39.850 | 3/6/20 | |
| Andree’ Pickens | Alabama | 39.850 | 3/16/02 | |
| Lexy Ramler | Minnesota | 39.850 | 2/26/21 | |
| Jeana Rice | Alabama | 39.850 | 3/20/04 | |
| Kate Richardson | UCLA | 39.850 | 1/10/04 | |
| Kyla Ross | UCLA | 39.850 | 2/16/19 | |
| Kyla Ross | UCLA | 39.850 | 3/3/19 | |
| Kyla Ross | UCLA | 39.850 | 4/6/19 | |
| Trinity Thomas | Florida | 39.850 | 2/25/22 | |
| Trinity Thomas | Florida | 39.850 | 2/17/23 | |
| Anastasia Webb | Oklahoma | 39.850 | 3/7/21 | |
| Leanne Wong | Florida | 39.850 | 3/11/22 | |
| 61. | Luisa Blanco | Alabama | 39.825 | 2/19/21 |
| Lynnzee Brown | Denver | 39.825 | 3/7/21 | |
| Haleigh Bryant | LSU | 39.825 | 1/19/24 | |
| Haleigh Bryant | LSU | 39.825 | 2/2/24 | |
| April Burkholder | LSU | 39.825 | 3/11/05 | |
| Sarah Cain | Michigan | 39.825 | 97 | |
| Jade Carey | Oregon St | 39.825 | 2/5/22 | |
| Jade Carey | Oregon St | 39.825 | 2/25/22 | |
| Jade Carey | Oregon St | 39.825 | 1/21/23 | |
| Jade Carey | Oregon St | 39.825 | 2/10/23 | |
| Jade Carey | Oregon St | 39.825 | 3/11/23 | |
| Jordan Chiles | UCLA | 39.825 | 2/11/23 | |
| Ashleigh Clare-Kearney | LSU | 39.825 | 4/12/08 | |
| Rheagan Courville | LSU | 39.825 | 2/6/15 | |
| Natalie Foley | Stanford | 39.825 | 2/20/04 | |
| Larissa Fontaine | Stanford | 39.825 | 2/21/00 | |
| eMjae Frazier | Cal | 39.825 | 2/25/24 | |
| eMjae Frazier | Cal | 39.825 | 3/10/24 | |
| Selena Harris | UCLA | 39.825 | 3/23/24 | |
| Jessica Hutchinson | Denver | 39.825 | 2/11/24 | |
| Jessica Hutchinson | Denver | 39.825 | 3/15/24 | |
| Alaina Johnson | Florida | 39.825 | 3/7/14 | |
| Courtney Kupets | Georgia | 39.825 | 1/23/09 | |
| Suni Lee | Auburn | 39.825 | 2/5/22 | |
| Suni Lee | Auburn | 39.825 | 2/3/23 | |
| Karin Lichey | Georgia | 39.825 | 1/22/99 | |
| Kristen Maloney | UCLA | 39.825 | 3/6/05 | |
| Grace McCallum | Utah | 39.825 | 3/15/24 | |
| Kelly McDonald | Washington | 39.825 | 2/13/04 | |
| Alex McMurtry | Florida | 39.825 | 3/9/18 | |
| Maggie Nichols | Oklahoma | 39.825 | 2/23/18 | |
| Maggie Nichols | Oklahoma | 39.825 | 1/17/20 | |
| Maggie Nichols | Oklahoma | 39.825 | 2/29/20 | |
| Elizabeth Price | Stanford | 39.825 | 3/11/18 | |
| Emily Pritchard | Washington | 39.825 | 3/5/04 | |
| Lexy Ramler | Minnesota | 39.825 | 1/24/22 | |
| Elise Ray | Michigan | 39.825 | 3/9/02 | |
| Kate Richardson | UCLA | 39.825 | 3/29/03 | |
| Kyla Ross | UCLA | 39.825 | 2/23/20 | |
| Tasha Schwikert | UCLA | 39.825 | 3/6/05 | |
| Richelle Simpson | Nebraska | 39.825 | 3/23/03 | |
| Bridget Sloan | Florida | 39.825 | 3/14/14 | |
| Trinity Thomas | Florida | 39.825 | 2/28/20 | |
| Trinity Thomas | Florida | 39.825 | 3/19/22 | |
| Trinity Thomas | Florida | 39.825 | 2/10/23 | |
| Lindsay Wing | Stanford | 39.825 | 2/20/04 | |
| Natalie Wojcik | Michigan | 39.825 | 2/4/22 | |
| Leanne Wong | Florida | 39.825 | 1/13/23 | |
| Beth Wymer | Michigan | 39.825 | 94 | |
| 110. | Alex McMurtry | Florida | 39.8125 | 4/14/17 |
| Maggie Nichols | Oklahoma | 39.8125 | 4/20/18 | |
| Trinity Thomas | Florida | 39.8125 | 4/14/22 | |
| 113. | Jeanette Antolin | UCLA | 39.800 | 1/19/04 |
| Kim Arnold | Georgia | 39.800 | 97 | |
| Kim Arnold | Georgia | 39.800 | 97 | |
| Mohini Bhardwaj | UCLA | 39.800 | 1/28/01 | |
| Mohini Bhardwaj | UCLA | 39.800 | 3/4/01 | |
| Luisa Blanco | Alabama | 39.800 | 3/20/21 | |
| Luisa Blanco | Alabama | 39.800 | 4/2/21 | |
| Jordan Bowers | Oklahoma | 39.800 | 2/23/24 | |
| Lynnzee Brown | Denver | 39.800 | 4/2/23 | |
| Haleigh Bryant | LSU | 39.800 | 2/24/23 | |
| Haleigh Bryant | LSU | 39.800 | 3/23/24 | |
| April Burkholder | LSU | 39.800 | 2/20/04 | |
| Chelsa Byrd | Georgia | 39.800 | 3/5/04 | |
| Jade Carey | Oregon State | 39.800 | 1/23/22 | |
| Jade Carey | Oregon State | 39.800 | 3/4/23 | |
| Jordan Chiles | UCLA | 39.800 | 3/6/22 | |
| Ashleigh Clare-Kearney | LSU | 39.800 | 2/29/08 | |
| Jamie Dantzscher | UCLA | 39.800 | 2/23/02 | |
| Kayla DiCello | Florida | 39.800 | 3/31/23 | |
| Aleah Finnegan | LSU | 39.800 | 2/10/23 | |
| Sarah Finnegan | LSU | 39.800 | 3/8/19 | |
| Sarah Finnegan | LSU | 39.800 | 3/23/19 | |
| Natalie Foley | Stanford | 39.800 | 3/20/04 | |
| Dee Foster | Alabama | 39.800 | 93 | |
| Dee Foster | Alabama | 39.800 | 93 | |
| Cory Fritzinger | Georgia | 39.800 | 1/13/02 | |
| Maggie Germaine | Arizona State | 39.800 | 3/12/04 | |
| Kristen Guise | Florida | 39.800 | 3/8/96 | |
| Jenny Hansen | Kentucky | 39.800 | 95 | |
| Abby Heiskell | Michigan | 39.800 | 2/3/23 | |
| Kytra Hunter | Florida | 39.800 | 3/1/13 | |
| Ashley Kelly | Arizona State | 39.800 | 3/5/04 | |
| Kristen Kenoyer | Utah | 39.800 | 4/3/93 | |
| Theresa Kulikowski | Utah | 39.800 | 2/15/02 | |
| Theresa Kulikowski | Utah | 39.800 | 3/23/02 | |
| Courtney Kupets | Georgia | 39.800 | 4/16/09 | |
| Courtney Kupets | Georgia | 39.800 | 3/11/06 | |
| Suni Lee | Auburn | 39.800 | 3/4/22 | |
| Alex McMurtry | Florida | 39.800 | 4/15/17 | |
| Maggie Nichols | Oklahoma | 39.800 | 3/16/18 | |
| Ashley Postell | Utah | 39.800 | 2/1/08 | |
| Elise Ray | Michigan | 39.800 | 3/20/04 | |
| Kate Richardson | UCLA | 39.800 | 2/22/04 | |
| Kyla Ross | UCLA | 39.800 | 3/23/19 | |
| Agina Simpkins | Gerogia | 39.800 | 93 | |
| Richelle Simpson | Nebraska | 39.800 | 2/23/03 | |
| Richelle Simpson | Nebraska | 39.800 | 3/29/03 | |
| Richelle Simpson | Nebraska | 39.800 | 4/25/03 | |
| Bridget Sloan | Florida | 39.800 | 4/4/15 | |
| Heather Stepp | Georgia | 39.800 | 93 | |
| Trinity Thomas | Florida | 39.800 | 3/18/23 | |
| Melissa Vituj | Utah | 39.800 | 3/19/04 | |
| Onnie Willis | UCLA | 39.800 | 1/19/03 | |
| Onnie Willis | UCLA | 39.800 | 2/9/03 | |
| Gabby Wilson | UCLA | 39.800 | 3/6/23 | |
| Beth Wymer | Michigan | 39.800 | 94 | |
| Beth Wymer | Michigan | 39.800 | 95 |